Thought for the Day
Good Morning Scotland
Radio Scotland
Tuesday, January 27th, 2009
Good morning.
Proposals are afoot at Westminster to deprive drug addicts of their benefits if they don’t sign up for medical treatment.
It’s one of those proposals that gets heads nodding in agreement – maybe too quickly.
It is so easy to scold.
“Getting tough” gets votes. Government money should not end up lining the pockets of drug dealers.
True,
but, for that matter, government money should not end up in the hands
of people who sell cheesy snacks instead of leafy green vegetables or
large screen televisions instead of books.
People will continue to make choices - whether they’re receiving government benefits or not.
The SNP government is seen as opposing the enactment of such legislation north of the border. For their pains they’ve been labelled ‘obstructive’.
I ran a 500 bed night-shelter in downtown Montreal for a number of years. Among
our clients were well-established addicts – men and women who generally
suffered under a cloud of problems – often psychiatric - which included substance addiction. Choice was them was limited – power of choice seemingly quite lost.
Of
enormous concern to us were the many thousands more who were not yet
‘sleeping rough’ – who were still in flats and still connected in some
way to their families. It is such a group which will be most affected by what is being proposed. There are children here and community and family ties. The
withdrawal of benefits leaves such individuals without accommodation,
nourishment or community and family support – it reduces people to a
form of life where the ability to choose is less likely to be operative -
the pointy end, essentially, of what is being proposed by the
Westminster government.
Jesus had strong words,
at one point in the Gospel story, for those who tied heavy burdens on
others while doing nothing to lift them themselves.
Support can be withdrawn with the flick of a pen.
But it is no victory. And it’s certainly not righteous.